Skip to main content

March 2021 Read of the Month Review

 Check off one of my 2021 Spring Break goals, I completed my March Read of the Month, Nick by Michael Farris Smith. Nick tells the story of Nick Carraway, the narrator in F. Scott Fitgerald's 1925 classic The Great Gatsby. Full disclosure, The Great Gatsby is one of my favorite books of all time, so keep that in mind as I review this book.

First thing, Sam Waterston is the only Nick Carraway, sorry Spiderman.....

First, a quick summary of this book without giving too much away. Nick opens in France during World War I, and we meet Nick as he is fighting the war and spending time on leave falling in love in Paris. During this time, and throughout the book, the reader is provided some flashbacks to Nick's childhood in Minnesota as well, we even get a sample of his father's famous speech that Carraway opens The Great Gatsby with; "In my younger and more vulnerable years my father gave me some advice that I've been turning over in my mind ever since. Whenever you feel like criticizing anyone, he told me, just remember that all the people in this world haven't had the advantages that you've had." 

The second half of the novel follows Nick as he returns from the war, but instead of going home he spends time in New Orleans. The novel concludes leading the reader right up to the opening of Gatsby, with Nick moving into a small cottage on Long Island. Speaking of that, here is Gatsby introducing himself to his new "neighbor" from the 1974 film version of The Great Gatsby.



A few general notes and thoughts:

  • The novel starts a little slow for me, I nearly gave up, but the war scenes toward the end of the first half of the book helped. I enjoyed the second half set in New Orleans much more than the first half.
  • I like Nick as a character (in both books) but he sure has some bad luck. He seems to put himself in some bad situations, but usually comes out clean and unharmed.
  • My ranking, if you are a Gatsby dork like myself I give it a 4/5, if you are just looking for a book and you are not a Gatsby fan, it is honestly more of a 2.5/3 out of 5
So there you have it. If you loved Gatsby you will probably "like" this book. If Gatsby was not your thing, you may just want to pass. Also, please do not come at me with your Tobey Maguire is the better Nick Carraway nonsense. He was find in Spiderman, but you know my feelings about Jack Mc.....I mean Sam Waterston. Happy Reading!



**Update, while researching for this review/entry I discovered The Great Gatsby entered the public domain on 1/1/2021. Michael Farris Smith had to wait for that to occur before he could publish this novel, very interesting.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Your Own Personal Library Catalog

So, how many of you have remember using an old style, card catalog?  You know, you want to find a book in your local library, so you pull out the long drawers flipping through cards.  Well those days are long gone of course (thankfully) and nearly all libraries use an electronic catalog system to keep track of their collections.  Many of the school districts in Wayne County are using a system developed by Follett .  It is a great system for school age children and prepares them for many of the advanced catalogs available in public and university libraries. Catalog software is quite expensive and really impractical for home libraries.  Some book lovers may create their own spreadsheet or database to keep track of their books, however there is a great (free) tool online to not only catalog your books, but also meet and communicate with other book lovers online.  The site  librarything.com is a wonderful site that lets you catalog your own home library.  Think of it as a "Facebook

A Once-In-A-Lifetime Event

Back in November I wrote about what I believe to be the best part of my job; running into Carlson High School graduates that are success stories and hearing about how well they are doing in the "real world."  Carlson High School graduate Nathan Matatall is clearly one of these success stories.  After graduating from Carlson High School and Michigan State University Nathan has gone on to very successful career at Dell Computers.  The News Herald even published a feature piece on Nathan a few years ago.  This past week, Nathan provided my family with a once-in-a-lifetime experience that I will never forget.   Nathan, my former public speaking student, contacted me via email a few weeks ago and inquired about taking my kids on a tour of Marine One (one of the helicopters used to transport The President of the United States and other dignitaries) and to possibly attend the landing of Air Force One when President Obama was scheduled to arrive in Detroit.  I was very excited a

A Little R & R

I decided to take a little R & R before things get crazy with back to school.  I wanted to spend some time with my family for these final weeks of summer, so I decided a break from writing was in order.  A trip to Kalahari and fun times with friends and family made August fly by.  So, what does school year 2014 bring for me?  Quite a bit, as always: Back to teaching two courses at Wayne County Community College.  Thursday evenings and Saturday mornings I head to Northline Road to teach college level English.  I really love this second job! Tuesday, I start my 17th year at O.A. Carlson High School.  While public education continues to face challenges, there is no other job for me at this time.  I love my co-workers and students.  Gibraltar is a great place to work. I will be running my kids all over as usual.  Gymnastics, religious education, flag football (which I coach as well), and others events "to be determined."  I would not have it any other way.  I love watch